Clever Tricks to Have a Family Meal with a Picky Eater - Your Kid's Table

Please note this post contains affiliate links that help support the information I share at Your Kid’s Table.

You can have one family meal with a picky eater and stop the short order cooking.

I’m thrilled to have FunBites sponsoring this post. They have been a great supporter of Your Kid’s Table and help me keep tips and info coming your way. FunBites fits in perfect around here because the creators and owners of this company designed their “fun” cutters to help their own picky eater at meals. FunBites isn’t just for picky eaters though, they are also really helpful for toddlers that need their food cut up into small bite sized shapes. See our picture below of putting these FunBites into action. Of course, I have the kids helping me, and these cutters are safe for even the youngest hands! Save 20% off your entire purchase with this code for our readers: YourKidsTable


Today, I want to cover a daily problem many of you are dealing with… navigating family meal times with a picky eater. Most parents with picky eaters want to give their kids what the rest of the family is eating, which is often something delicious and nutritionally sound. But, they know their “picky eater” won’t even consider trying it. Frequently, parents find themselves preparing a separate meal for this child. I know that parents feel stuck and while they don’t want to be short order cooking, they also don’t want their kids to go to bed hungry, a horrible thought especially for younger kids. So, what’s a parent to do? It is a question I get asked very often!

A great starting place to starting point to combat picky-eating is my basic strategies plan, but even better is showing up for the free live 3 Keys to Turn Your Picky Eater Around Workshop because I’m going to go over my basic plan with you in person. I know for a fact that this LIVE workshop will be helpful. This is a rare chance to catch me live, and interact


 with me. Make sure you get a seat before they are filled up and share it with your friends and family on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter, because almost everyone has a picky eater they need help with.

Setting the Stage

If you’ve read the Eating Basics tab in the menu bar or any one of a large variety of articles I’ve written here, then you know I consistently preach 2 things parents must follow to begin to see progress, without them any other efforts will most likely not get results.

Having one family everyone can eat with a picky eater may seem impossible, but with simple plan you CAN make one meal for everyone to eat!


1. Meals must be spaced at least 2.5-3 hours apart with nothing in between but water. This ensures your child will have an appetite when they sit down to the meal.

2. Always serve at least one preferred food (aka: something they will actually eat).
I’m already ahead of you because I know what your next question is… “What if they only eat a handful of foods?” The short answer is that you will begin with rotating at least one of those foods at each meal. Now, I know it isn’t always that simple, and surely through my private and community practices I have seen a wide range of food preferences. Plus, if you follow along here, you know that I am dealing with this personally as a parent also. Believe me, I get it! 

My goal in this post is to show you exactly how to make reasonable accommodations for the picky eater in your life without losing your sanity or sacrificing the quality of your other children’s eating. With that being said, this post isn’t going to talk a lot about how to improve the picky eater’s variety. Don’t be disappointed though, if you are looking for specific strategies to get your picky eater eating more, there is a ton of info in other articles I’ve written. See the Picky Eating section under the Article Index tab in the menu bar. 

My Own Little Selective Eater

Although we have come a very long way with my son, there are still some foods we regularly eat that he doesn’t. I’m going to be really honest here and say that is okay with me most days. We have a system in place that keeps meals positive and we usually encourage him to interact with the food in a positive way, but as a mom I don’t always have the energy to work on him eating something new, nor do I constantly want him to be the center of attention at meals for his and and everyone else’s sake.

I can rest easy because I know he is still being exposed to these non-preferred foods, but also has something to fill his tummy enough until the next meal. I’m going to use Isaac, my son, as an example of how I manage my family meals so that you can draw some similar parallels with foods that your child likes to eat. It takes some pre-planning, but it is worth the effort by the time kids are coming to the table.

So let me give you a little background on Isaac so that you can see my line of thought as I’m preparing a meal:

  • Likes: Carbs of any kind. There isn’t a bread, chip, or cracker that he turns down, and I’m careful to maximize exposing him to a wide variety in this category of food. He also consistently eats cheese, nuts, desserts, and most fruits.
  • Challenges: He struggles with most meats outside of bacon, ham, and the occasional chicken or fish nuggets. Mixed foods, like casseroles, potatoes (other than french fries), and veggies (other than raw carrots) are hard for him.

Obviously, I could just serve bread every night with a meal, but I don’t want that to become something he assumes will always be there. I make a concerted effort to rotate the foods he likes as part of our dinners. If your child only has a few foods they consistently eat, you may only be able to do this once a week. On the other nights that we are having a casserole or mostly foods he will eat little to none of, I make sure I rotate in one of those additional sides that I likely wouldn’t have served.

For example, the other night I made an enchilada casserole that everyone else enjoys, on the side I served tortilla chips and raw carrots (two preferred foods) that I otherwise wouldn’t have, but were little effort and didn’t detract from the meal for anyone else. Whenever I can, I try to have the additional Isaac food compliment whatever the rest of the meal is. I also don’t let the kids realize that this food is mostly for Isaac, I put it out for everyone. I’m also willing to deconstruct the casserole and serve some of it separately. This doesn’t always work logistically, but when it does I use it.

Serve Yourself

Another valuable element is to allow kids to serve themselves, as it gets them interacting with foods they may not eat (See my post on Serving Family Style). I would suggest making it a rule that everyone has to take some of everything even if it is just a small spoonful. It is their choice if they eat it. However, since picky eaters just want their preferred food, do you allow them just to eat mass quantities of it and ignore all the other foods? The answer isn’t a straight forward one.

I recommend, at a minimum, encouraging your child to interact with the other food in some way, usually by demonstrating yourself. For example, can they look at, touch, smell, kiss, or lick the food? You want to meet them where they are and try not to aim too high initially. I want to be clear, though, that you are NOT rewarding them with their preferred food. Try to avoid negotiating with phrases like, “If you take another bite you can have more bread.” Or, “Three more pieces of broccoli and you can have some more cheese.”  A helpful phrase to use instead is, “We need to eat (or interact/explore) our foods.”

Mealtime Examples

Here are some more examples of dinners we’ve had that I’ve added a preferred food to. Again, notice how I’m trying to have it go with what we are eating and that I’m maximizing every category of food he eats. I’ve highlighted the food I’ve added in.

1. Eggrolls, Fried Rice, Peanuts, and Applesauce

2. Lasagna, Garlic Bread, and Extra Broken Lasagna Noodles

3. Pork Chops, Parsley Potatoes, Carrots (both cooked and some raw), and Corn Bread

4. Chicken Pot Pie (Eats Crust), Pureed Butternut Squash Soup

5. Baked Potato Bar with Broccoli, Cheese, Sour Cream, and Bacon

6. Sauteed Fish, Steamed Brown RiceDiced Melon, and Broccoli

7. Hamburgers with Whole Wheat BunFrench Fries, and Diced Tomatoes

Isaac may eat some of these other foods that aren’t on his preferred list, but if he doesn’t, I know that there are enough other options there for him in case he doesn’t. If for some reason he decides to not eat even his preferred food, that is on him as long as I know we have waited that 2.5-3 hour mark I mentioned at the beginning of the post. I make sure to remind him before he leaves the table that there won’t be any food until the next meal, and I follow through. 

Helpful Tips

Remember that I wouldn’t serve all these “challenging” meals in a row, I alternate with meals that include several preferred foods so that he is meeting more of his nutritional needs. Ideally, at any meal I would like a child to eat an appropriate portion of a fruit/veggie, carb/starch, and protein.  

At the same time, you don’t want to go the other way and be serving 10 things for dinner trying to make it all seem like the same meal. At times, I have to let go of the fact that he isn’t eating a fruit or veggie at a particular meal. I can do this because I’ve offered one and he has chosen not to eat it. Of course, I don’t want this to go on meal after meal, so I will try to make up for it in either the meal before or after by serving something preferred in the category (usually fruit/veggie) that he is lacking.

If your child is in the problem feeder category it would still be helpful to follow these suggestions, but you are going to be a lot more limited in terms of variety of preferred foods. I would highly recommend focusing on increasing variety at the same time, more on that here and here, and/or seek out help from a feeding therapist.

Lastly, since I meal plan for a whole month ahead of time, I try to remind the kids earlier in the day what we are eating that night for dinner so there isn’t any disappointment or surprise. As much as I can, I try to get the kids to help cook or prepare some part of the dinner, especially when it is something new or a casserole. This is a great time to use those FunBites, as well. 

If you haven’t already, don’t forget to sign up for the FREE 3 Keys to Finally Turn Your Picky Eater Around Workshop!!!

Get the Toddler Food Printable Pack!

Get inspired, plan your meals, or just copy the done for you meal ideas with this awesome printable for toddlers and babies!

Select One...

Success! Now check your email to download your free printable!

Join Waitlist

You have Successfully Subscribed!